0

Philosophical Zombies and the Explanatory Gap

Description: This quiz aims to evaluate your understanding of the concept of philosophical zombies and the explanatory gap in the philosophy of mind.
Number of Questions: 15
Created by:
Tags: philosophy of mind philosophical zombies explanatory gap
Attempted 0/15 Correct 0 Score 0

What are philosophical zombies?

  1. Hypothetical beings that are physically identical to humans but lack consciousness.

  2. Beings that exist in a parallel universe where consciousness is not a necessary property of physical matter.

  3. Beings that are created through artificial intelligence and lack consciousness.

  4. Beings that are capable of experiencing consciousness but choose not to.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

Philosophical zombies are hypothetical beings that are physically identical to humans but lack consciousness. They are often used in philosophical arguments to challenge the idea that consciousness is a necessary property of physical matter.

What is the explanatory gap?

  1. The gap between the physical properties of the brain and the subjective experience of consciousness.

  2. The gap between the laws of physics and the laws of consciousness.

  3. The gap between the material world and the mental world.

  4. The gap between the brain and the mind.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The explanatory gap is the gap between the physical properties of the brain and the subjective experience of consciousness. It is a problem in the philosophy of mind because it is unclear how physical processes in the brain can give rise to subjective conscious experiences.

Which philosopher is most closely associated with the concept of philosophical zombies?

  1. David Chalmers

  2. Thomas Nagel

  3. Daniel Dennett

  4. John Searle


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

David Chalmers is a philosopher who is most closely associated with the concept of philosophical zombies. He has argued that the existence of philosophical zombies is a possibility that cannot be ruled out, and that this has implications for our understanding of the relationship between consciousness and the physical world.

What is the main argument for the possibility of philosophical zombies?

  1. The argument from conceivability.

  2. The argument from introspection.

  3. The argument from analogy.

  4. The argument from evolution.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The main argument for the possibility of philosophical zombies is the argument from conceivability. This argument states that it is possible to conceive of a being that is physically identical to a human but lacks consciousness. If it is possible to conceive of such a being, then it is possible that such a being exists.

What are some of the implications of the possibility of philosophical zombies?

  1. That consciousness is not a necessary property of physical matter.

  2. That the laws of physics are incomplete.

  3. That the material world is not all that there is.

  4. All of the above.


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

The possibility of philosophical zombies has a number of implications, including that consciousness is not a necessary property of physical matter, that the laws of physics are incomplete, and that the material world is not all that there is.

What is the most common objection to the argument from conceivability?

  1. The objection from intuition.

  2. The objection from science.

  3. The objection from logic.

  4. The objection from metaphysics.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The most common objection to the argument from conceivability is the objection from intuition. This objection states that it is simply impossible to conceive of a being that is physically identical to a human but lacks consciousness. However, this objection is controversial, and there are a number of philosophers who argue that it is possible to conceive of such a being.

What is the main argument against the possibility of philosophical zombies?

  1. The argument from coherence.

  2. The argument from naturalism.

  3. The argument from materialism.

  4. The argument from functionalism.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The main argument against the possibility of philosophical zombies is the argument from coherence. This argument states that the concept of a philosophical zombie is incoherent because it is impossible to conceive of a being that is physically identical to a human but lacks consciousness. However, this argument is also controversial, and there are a number of philosophers who argue that it is possible to conceive of such a being.

What is the relationship between the explanatory gap and the problem of other minds?

  1. The explanatory gap is a more general problem than the problem of other minds.

  2. The problem of other minds is a more general problem than the explanatory gap.

  3. The explanatory gap and the problem of other minds are the same problem.

  4. The explanatory gap and the problem of other minds are unrelated.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The explanatory gap is a more general problem than the problem of other minds. The explanatory gap is the problem of how physical processes in the brain can give rise to subjective conscious experiences. The problem of other minds is the problem of how we can know that other people have conscious experiences. The explanatory gap is a more general problem because it applies to all conscious experiences, not just the conscious experiences of other people.

What are some of the proposed solutions to the explanatory gap?

  1. Physicalism

  2. Dualism

  3. Neutral monism

  4. Panpsychism


Correct Option:
Explanation:

There are a number of proposed solutions to the explanatory gap, including physicalism, dualism, neutral monism, and panpsychism. Physicalism is the view that everything is physical. Dualism is the view that there are two fundamental substances, physical matter and consciousness. Neutral monism is the view that there is only one fundamental substance, which is neither physical nor mental. Panpsychism is the view that everything has some degree of consciousness.

Which of the following is NOT a property that philosophical zombies are typically said to have?

  1. They are physically identical to humans.

  2. They lack consciousness.

  3. They are capable of rational thought.

  4. They are capable of feeling emotions.


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

Philosophical zombies are typically said to lack consciousness, but they are often also said to be capable of rational thought and feeling emotions. This is because these properties are not necessarily dependent on consciousness.

What is the main objection to physicalism as a solution to the explanatory gap?

  1. The objection from qualia.

  2. The objection from introspection.

  3. The objection from science.

  4. The objection from logic.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The main objection to physicalism as a solution to the explanatory gap is the objection from qualia. Qualia are the subjective, qualitative aspects of conscious experience, such as the taste of coffee or the feeling of pain. Physicalists argue that qualia can be explained in terms of physical processes in the brain, but many philosophers argue that this is impossible.

What is the main objection to dualism as a solution to the explanatory gap?

  1. The objection from interaction.

  2. The objection from parsimony.

  3. The objection from science.

  4. The objection from logic.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The main objection to dualism as a solution to the explanatory gap is the objection from interaction. This objection states that it is impossible for a non-physical mind to interact with a physical body. However, this objection is controversial, and there are a number of philosophers who argue that it is possible for a non-physical mind to interact with a physical body.

What is the main objection to neutral monism as a solution to the explanatory gap?

  1. The objection from qualia.

  2. The objection from introspection.

  3. The objection from science.

  4. The objection from logic.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The main objection to neutral monism as a solution to the explanatory gap is the objection from qualia. This objection states that it is impossible for a neutral substance to have subjective, qualitative experiences. However, this objection is controversial, and there are a number of philosophers who argue that it is possible for a neutral substance to have subjective, qualitative experiences.

What is the main objection to panpsychism as a solution to the explanatory gap?

  1. The objection from parsimony.

  2. The objection from science.

  3. The objection from logic.

  4. The objection from common sense.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The main objection to panpsychism as a solution to the explanatory gap is the objection from parsimony. This objection states that panpsychism is a more complex and less parsimonious theory than other theories of consciousness, such as physicalism, dualism, and neutral monism. However, this objection is controversial, and there are a number of philosophers who argue that panpsychism is a more parsimonious theory than other theories of consciousness.

What is the current state of the debate over the explanatory gap?

  1. There is a consensus among philosophers that the explanatory gap has been closed.

  2. There is a consensus among philosophers that the explanatory gap is a real problem.

  3. There is no consensus among philosophers about the explanatory gap.

  4. The debate over the explanatory gap is irrelevant to the study of consciousness.


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

There is no consensus among philosophers about the explanatory gap. Some philosophers argue that the explanatory gap is a real problem, while others argue that it has been closed. There is also no consensus among philosophers about which solution to the explanatory gap is the best.

- Hide questions