0

Epistemic Closure and the Problem of Internalism

Description: Epistemic Closure and the Problem of Internalism
Number of Questions: 15
Created by:
Tags: epistemology internalism epistemic closure
Attempted 0/15 Correct 0 Score 0

What is the central idea behind epistemic closure?

  1. Knowledge is closed under logical implication.

  2. Knowledge is closed under deductive argument.

  3. Knowledge is closed under inductive argument.

  4. Knowledge is closed under probabilistic reasoning.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

Epistemic closure states that if one knows a set of propositions, then one also knows all of the logical consequences of those propositions.

What is the problem of internalism in epistemology?

  1. The problem of justifying beliefs that are not based on experience.

  2. The problem of explaining how knowledge can be acquired through experience.

  3. The problem of reconciling the internal and external aspects of knowledge.

  4. The problem of distinguishing between knowledge and belief.


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

The problem of internalism is the problem of explaining how knowledge can be justified both by internal factors (such as one's own beliefs and experiences) and by external factors (such as the evidence and the testimony of others).

Which philosopher is most closely associated with the defense of internalism in epistemology?

  1. René Descartes

  2. John Locke

  3. David Hume

  4. Immanuel Kant


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

René Descartes is most closely associated with the defense of internalism in epistemology. He argued that the only things that can be known with certainty are those that are known through introspection.

Which philosopher is most closely associated with the critique of internalism in epistemology?

  1. David Hume

  2. Immanuel Kant

  3. G.E. Moore

  4. Bertrand Russell


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

David Hume is most closely associated with the critique of internalism in epistemology. He argued that all knowledge is derived from experience, and that there is no way to justify beliefs that are not based on experience.

What is the main argument against epistemic closure?

  1. It is possible to know a proposition without knowing all of its logical consequences.

  2. It is possible to know a proposition even if it is false.

  3. It is possible to know a proposition even if it is not justified.

  4. It is possible to know a proposition even if it is not certain.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The main argument against epistemic closure is that it is possible to know a proposition without knowing all of its logical consequences. For example, one might know that all bachelors are unmarried, but not know that all unmarried men are bachelors.

What is the main argument in favor of epistemic closure?

  1. It is impossible to know a proposition without knowing all of its logical consequences.

  2. It is impossible to know a proposition if it is false.

  3. It is impossible to know a proposition if it is not justified.

  4. It is impossible to know a proposition if it is not certain.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The main argument in favor of epistemic closure is that it is impossible to know a proposition without knowing all of its logical consequences. This is because if one does not know all of the logical consequences of a proposition, then one cannot be sure that the proposition is true.

How does epistemic closure relate to the problem of skepticism?

  1. Epistemic closure provides a solution to the problem of skepticism.

  2. Epistemic closure exacerbates the problem of skepticism.

  3. Epistemic closure is unrelated to the problem of skepticism.

  4. Epistemic closure is a form of skepticism.


Correct Option: B
Explanation:

Epistemic closure exacerbates the problem of skepticism because it shows that even if one has knowledge of a certain proposition, one cannot be sure that one knows all of the logical consequences of that proposition. This means that one can never be sure that one's knowledge is complete and secure.

What is the main challenge facing internalists in epistemology?

  1. The problem of skepticism

  2. The problem of induction

  3. The problem of other minds

  4. The problem of free will


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The main challenge facing internalists in epistemology is the problem of skepticism. Skeptics argue that it is impossible to know anything for certain, and that all of our beliefs are ultimately unjustified. Internalists must find a way to respond to this challenge and show that it is possible to have knowledge of the external world.

What is the main challenge facing externalists in epistemology?

  1. The problem of skepticism

  2. The problem of induction

  3. The problem of other minds

  4. The problem of free will


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

The main challenge facing externalists in epistemology is the problem of other minds. Externalists argue that knowledge is based on evidence and experience, and that the only way to know about the mental states of others is through their behavior. However, skeptics argue that it is impossible to know for certain that other people have minds like our own.

Which of the following is an example of an internalist epistemological theory?

  1. Empiricism

  2. Rationalism

  3. Skepticism

  4. Externalism


Correct Option: B
Explanation:

Rationalism is an internalist epistemological theory that holds that knowledge is derived from reason and introspection, rather than from experience. Rationalists argue that the mind has innate knowledge of certain truths, and that these truths can be known through introspection.

Which of the following is an example of an externalist epistemological theory?

  1. Empiricism

  2. Rationalism

  3. Skepticism

  4. Externalism


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

Empiricism is an externalist epistemological theory that holds that knowledge is derived from experience. Empiricists argue that the mind is a blank slate at birth, and that all knowledge is acquired through experience. They also argue that the only way to know about the external world is through our senses.

What is the main difference between internalism and externalism in epistemology?

  1. Internalists believe that knowledge is derived from reason and introspection, while externalists believe that knowledge is derived from experience.

  2. Internalists believe that knowledge is justified by internal factors, while externalists believe that knowledge is justified by external factors.

  3. Internalists believe that knowledge is certain, while externalists believe that knowledge is uncertain.

  4. Internalists believe that knowledge is subjective, while externalists believe that knowledge is objective.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The main difference between internalism and externalism in epistemology is that internalists believe that knowledge is derived from reason and introspection, while externalists believe that knowledge is derived from experience.

Which of the following is an example of an epistemic closure principle?

  1. If you know that A, then you know that A or B.

  2. If you know that A, then you know that not A.

  3. If you know that A, then you know that A implies B.

  4. If you know that A, then you know that B implies A.


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

An epistemic closure principle is a principle that states that if you know a proposition, then you also know all of its logical consequences. The principle 'If you know that A, then you know that A implies B' is an example of an epistemic closure principle.

Which of the following is an example of a violation of epistemic closure?

  1. You know that all bachelors are unmarried, but you do not know that all unmarried men are bachelors.

  2. You know that all dogs are mammals, but you do not know that all mammals are dogs.

  3. You know that all cats are animals, but you do not know that all animals are cats.

  4. You know that all humans are mortal, but you do not know that all mortals are humans.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

A violation of epistemic closure occurs when you know a proposition but do not know one of its logical consequences. The example 'You know that all bachelors are unmarried, but you do not know that all unmarried men are bachelors' is an example of a violation of epistemic closure.

What is the main problem with the epistemic closure principle?

  1. It is too strong.

  2. It is too weak.

  3. It is circular.

  4. It is self-contradictory.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The main problem with the epistemic closure principle is that it is too strong. It states that if you know a proposition, then you know all of its logical consequences. However, this is not always the case. For example, you might know that all bachelors are unmarried, but you might not know that all unmarried men are bachelors.

- Hide questions