Back
0

The Implications of Internalism and Externalism for Historical Epistemology

Description: This quiz evaluates your understanding of the implications of internalism and externalism for historical epistemology.
Number of Questions: 14
Created by:
Tags: epistemology internalism externalism historical epistemology
Start the Quiz
Attempted 0/14 Correct 0 Score 0
‹
›

Which of the following is a central tenet of internalism?

  1. Knowledge is justified true belief.

  2. Knowledge is independent of the knower's external environment.

  3. Knowledge is socially constructed.

  4. Knowledge is fallible.

Show answer
Correct Option: A
Explanation:

Internalism holds that knowledge is a matter of the individual knower's mental states, such as beliefs, justifications, and evidence.

According to externalism, what is the primary determinant of knowledge?

  1. The knower's mental states.

  2. The knower's external environment.

  3. The knower's social interactions.

  4. The knower's cultural background.

Show answer
Correct Option: B
Explanation:

Externalism argues that knowledge is dependent on factors external to the knower, such as the state of the world, the knower's social interactions, and the knower's cultural background.

Which of the following is an implication of internalism for historical epistemology?

  1. Historical knowledge is objective and independent of the historian's perspective.

  2. Historical knowledge is subjective and shaped by the historian's perspective.

  3. Historical knowledge is impossible to obtain.

  4. Historical knowledge is always provisional and subject to revision.

Show answer
Correct Option: B
Explanation:

Internalism implies that historical knowledge is subjective because it is dependent on the historian's mental states, such as their beliefs, justifications, and evidence, which are shaped by their perspective.

According to externalism, how does the historian's external environment influence historical knowledge?

  1. The historian's external environment provides the evidence for historical claims.

  2. The historian's external environment shapes the historian's perspective.

  3. The historian's external environment determines the truth of historical claims.

  4. The historian's external environment is irrelevant to historical knowledge.

Show answer
Correct Option: B
Explanation:

Externalism argues that the historian's external environment, such as their social interactions, cultural background, and access to evidence, shapes their perspective, which in turn influences their historical knowledge.

Which of the following is a potential criticism of internalism in the context of historical epistemology?

  1. Internalism fails to account for the role of evidence in historical knowledge.

  2. Internalism implies that historical knowledge is objective and independent of the historian's perspective.

  3. Internalism denies the possibility of historical skepticism.

  4. Internalism is compatible with the idea that historical knowledge is fallible.

Show answer
Correct Option: A
Explanation:

Internalism has been criticized for failing to adequately account for the role of evidence in historical knowledge, as it focuses primarily on the historian's mental states rather than the external factors that contribute to historical knowledge.

How does externalism address the problem of historical skepticism?

  1. Externalism provides a foundation for historical knowledge that is independent of the historian's perspective.

  2. Externalism shows that historical skepticism is a valid philosophical position.

  3. Externalism argues that historical knowledge is impossible to obtain.

  4. Externalism denies the existence of historical skepticism.

Show answer
Correct Option: A
Explanation:

Externalism addresses the problem of historical skepticism by arguing that historical knowledge is not dependent solely on the historian's mental states, but also on external factors such as evidence and the historian's social and cultural context.

Which of the following is an implication of externalism for the objectivity of historical knowledge?

  1. Historical knowledge is objective and independent of the historian's perspective.

  2. Historical knowledge is subjective and shaped by the historian's perspective.

  3. Historical knowledge is impossible to obtain.

  4. Historical knowledge is always provisional and subject to revision.

Show answer
Correct Option: A
Explanation:

Externalism implies that historical knowledge can be objective and independent of the historian's perspective, as it is based on factors external to the historian, such as evidence and the historian's social and cultural context.

How does internalism account for the fact that different historians often reach different conclusions about the same historical events?

  1. Internalism argues that different historians have different perspectives, which lead them to interpret the evidence differently.

  2. Internalism denies that different historians often reach different conclusions about the same historical events.

  3. Internalism claims that historical knowledge is objective and independent of the historian's perspective.

  4. Internalism maintains that historical knowledge is impossible to obtain.

Show answer
Correct Option: A
Explanation:

Internalism acknowledges that different historians may have different perspectives and interpretations of the evidence, which can lead them to reach different conclusions about the same historical events.

According to externalism, what is the relationship between historical knowledge and the historian's social and cultural context?

  1. The historian's social and cultural context is irrelevant to historical knowledge.

  2. The historian's social and cultural context shapes the historian's perspective, which in turn influences historical knowledge.

  3. The historian's social and cultural context determines the truth of historical claims.

  4. The historian's social and cultural context provides the evidence for historical claims.

Show answer
Correct Option: B
Explanation:

Externalism argues that the historian's social and cultural context shapes their perspective, which in turn influences their interpretation of the evidence and their conclusions about historical events.

Which of the following is a potential criticism of externalism in the context of historical epistemology?

  1. Externalism implies that historical knowledge is objective and independent of the historian's perspective.

  2. Externalism fails to account for the role of the historian's mental states in historical knowledge.

  3. Externalism denies the possibility of historical skepticism.

  4. Externalism is compatible with the idea that historical knowledge is fallible.

Show answer
Correct Option: B
Explanation:

Externalism has been criticized for failing to adequately account for the role of the historian's mental states, such as their beliefs, justifications, and evidence, in historical knowledge, as it focuses primarily on external factors.

How does internalism address the problem of historical relativism?

  1. Internalism argues that historical knowledge is objective and independent of the historian's perspective.

  2. Internalism denies the existence of historical relativism.

  3. Internalism claims that historical knowledge is impossible to obtain.

  4. Internalism maintains that historical knowledge is always provisional and subject to revision.

Show answer
Correct Option: B
Explanation:

Internalism denies the existence of historical relativism by arguing that historical knowledge is based on objective evidence and rational justification, rather than being solely dependent on the historian's perspective.

According to externalism, what is the role of evidence in historical knowledge?

  1. Evidence is irrelevant to historical knowledge.

  2. Evidence provides the foundation for historical claims.

  3. Evidence is shaped by the historian's perspective.

  4. Evidence is determined by the truth of historical claims.

Show answer
Correct Option: B
Explanation:

Externalism argues that evidence plays a crucial role in historical knowledge, as it provides the foundation for historical claims and helps historians to evaluate the accuracy and reliability of their interpretations.

Which of the following is an implication of internalism for the fallibility of historical knowledge?

  1. Historical knowledge is infallible and immune to error.

  2. Historical knowledge is always provisional and subject to revision.

  3. Historical knowledge is impossible to obtain.

  4. Historical knowledge is objective and independent of the historian's perspective.

Show answer
Correct Option: B
Explanation:

Internalism implies that historical knowledge is fallible and subject to revision, as it is based on the historian's mental states, which are fallible and subject to change.

How does externalism account for the fact that historical knowledge often changes over time?

  1. Externalism argues that historical knowledge is objective and unchanging.

  2. Externalism denies that historical knowledge changes over time.

  3. Externalism claims that historical knowledge is impossible to obtain.

  4. Externalism maintains that historical knowledge changes over time due to the discovery of new evidence and the changing perspectives of historians.

Show answer
Correct Option: D
Explanation:

Externalism argues that historical knowledge changes over time due to the discovery of new evidence, the changing perspectives of historians, and the evolving social and cultural contexts in which historical knowledge is produced.

- Hide questions
ADVERTISEMENT

Find more quizzes from top tags

general knowledge
3615 Quizzes
119858 Questions
 technology
307 Quizzes
36705 Questions
 sports
963 Quizzes
19148 Questions
 history
1187 Quizzes
13475 Questions
 physics
598 Quizzes
13441 Questions
 biology
1160 Quizzes
12174 Questions
 science & technology
551 Quizzes
11015 Questions
 chemistry
490 Quizzes
9892 Questions
 maths
518 Quizzes
9324 Questions
 softskills
0 Quizzes
7131 Questions