0

Epistemic Closure and the Problem of Infinite Regress

Description: Epistemic Closure and the Problem of Infinite Regress Quiz
Number of Questions: 14
Created by:
Tags: epistemology epistemic closure infinite regress
Attempted 0/14 Correct 0 Score 0

What is epistemic closure?

  1. The idea that knowledge is self-contained and does not require external justification.

  2. The idea that knowledge is always provisional and subject to revision.

  3. The idea that knowledge is a social construct and is dependent on the beliefs of others.

  4. The idea that knowledge is a private matter and is not accessible to others.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

Epistemic closure is the idea that knowledge is self-contained and does not require external justification. This means that if you know something, then you do not need to justify your knowledge to anyone else.

What is the problem of infinite regress?

  1. The problem that arises when you try to justify your knowledge by appealing to other beliefs, which in turn need to be justified by other beliefs, and so on.

  2. The problem that arises when you try to explain something by appealing to other things, which in turn need to be explained by other things, and so on.

  3. The problem that arises when you try to prove something by appealing to other statements, which in turn need to be proved by other statements, and so on.

  4. The problem that arises when you try to define something by appealing to other terms, which in turn need to be defined by other terms, and so on.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The problem of infinite regress arises when you try to justify your knowledge by appealing to other beliefs, which in turn need to be justified by other beliefs, and so on. This can lead to an infinite chain of justification, which is impossible to complete.

How is epistemic closure related to the problem of infinite regress?

  1. Epistemic closure is a solution to the problem of infinite regress.

  2. Epistemic closure is a cause of the problem of infinite regress.

  3. Epistemic closure is unrelated to the problem of infinite regress.

  4. Epistemic closure is both a solution and a cause of the problem of infinite regress.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

Epistemic closure is a solution to the problem of infinite regress because it allows you to justify your knowledge without appealing to other beliefs. This means that you can avoid the infinite chain of justification that leads to the problem of infinite regress.

What are some arguments for epistemic closure?

  1. The argument from coherence: The idea that knowledge is a coherent system of beliefs that is self-supporting.

  2. The argument from foundationalism: The idea that knowledge is based on a foundation of self-evident beliefs.

  3. The argument from skepticism: The idea that it is impossible to justify our knowledge, so we should accept epistemic closure as a practical necessity.

  4. All of the above.


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

There are a number of arguments for epistemic closure, including the argument from coherence, the argument from foundationalism, and the argument from skepticism.

What are some arguments against epistemic closure?

  1. The argument from dogmatism: The idea that epistemic closure leads to dogmatism and intolerance.

  2. The argument from relativism: The idea that epistemic closure leads to relativism and the denial of objective truth.

  3. The argument from progress: The idea that epistemic closure prevents us from making progress in our knowledge.

  4. All of the above.


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

There are a number of arguments against epistemic closure, including the argument from dogmatism, the argument from relativism, and the argument from progress.

Do you think epistemic closure is a valid concept?

  1. Yes

  2. No

  3. I'm not sure.


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

There are strong arguments both for and against epistemic closure. Ultimately, whether or not you think it is a valid concept is a matter of personal opinion.

What are some ways to avoid the problem of infinite regress?

  1. Appeal to a foundation of self-evident beliefs.

  2. Accept epistemic closure as a practical necessity.

  3. Use a method of justification that does not require an infinite chain of justification.

  4. All of the above.


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

There are a number of ways to avoid the problem of infinite regress, including appealing to a foundation of self-evident beliefs, accepting epistemic closure as a practical necessity, and using a method of justification that does not require an infinite chain of justification.

Which of the following is an example of epistemic closure?

  1. Believing that the Earth is round because you have seen it from space.

  2. Believing that the sun is hot because you have felt its heat.

  3. Believing that 2 + 2 = 4 because it is a self-evident truth.

  4. All of the above.


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

All of the above are examples of epistemic closure because they are beliefs that do not require external justification.

Which of the following is an example of the problem of infinite regress?

  1. Trying to justify your belief that the Earth is round by appealing to the fact that you have seen it from space.

  2. Trying to justify your belief that the sun is hot by appealing to the fact that you have felt its heat.

  3. Trying to justify your belief that 2 + 2 = 4 by appealing to the fact that it is a self-evident truth.

  4. All of the above.


Correct Option:
Explanation:

None of the above are examples of the problem of infinite regress because they do not involve an infinite chain of justification.

What is the relationship between epistemic closure and skepticism?

  1. Epistemic closure is a response to skepticism.

  2. Epistemic closure is a cause of skepticism.

  3. Epistemic closure is unrelated to skepticism.

  4. Epistemic closure is both a response to and a cause of skepticism.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

Epistemic closure is a response to skepticism because it provides a way to justify our knowledge without appealing to external sources of justification. This can help to undermine skeptical arguments that claim that it is impossible to justify our knowledge.

What is the relationship between epistemic closure and dogmatism?

  1. Epistemic closure is a form of dogmatism.

  2. Epistemic closure is opposed to dogmatism.

  3. Epistemic closure is unrelated to dogmatism.

  4. Epistemic closure can be both a form of dogmatism and opposed to dogmatism.


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

Epistemic closure can be both a form of dogmatism and opposed to dogmatism. On the one hand, epistemic closure can lead to dogmatism if it is used to justify beliefs that are not open to revision. On the other hand, epistemic closure can be opposed to dogmatism if it is used to justify beliefs that are based on evidence and reason.

What is the relationship between epistemic closure and relativism?

  1. Epistemic closure is a form of relativism.

  2. Epistemic closure is opposed to relativism.

  3. Epistemic closure is unrelated to relativism.

  4. Epistemic closure can be both a form of relativism and opposed to relativism.


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

Epistemic closure can be both a form of relativism and opposed to relativism. On the one hand, epistemic closure can lead to relativism if it is used to justify beliefs that are based on the beliefs of a particular group of people. On the other hand, epistemic closure can be opposed to relativism if it is used to justify beliefs that are based on evidence and reason.

What is the relationship between epistemic closure and progress?

  1. Epistemic closure is a barrier to progress.

  2. Epistemic closure is a necessary condition for progress.

  3. Epistemic closure is unrelated to progress.

  4. Epistemic closure can be both a barrier to progress and a necessary condition for progress.


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

Epistemic closure can be both a barrier to progress and a necessary condition for progress. On the one hand, epistemic closure can lead to a lack of progress if it is used to justify beliefs that are not open to revision. On the other hand, epistemic closure can be a necessary condition for progress if it is used to justify beliefs that are based on evidence and reason.

What are some of the most important philosophical implications of epistemic closure?

  1. Epistemic closure raises questions about the nature of knowledge and justification.

  2. Epistemic closure raises questions about the relationship between knowledge and belief.

  3. Epistemic closure raises questions about the possibility of progress in our knowledge.

  4. All of the above.


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

Epistemic closure raises questions about the nature of knowledge and justification, the relationship between knowledge and belief, and the possibility of progress in our knowledge.

- Hide questions