0

Critical Reasoning Test 3

Description: Critical Reasoning Tests - Free Online Reasoning Tests for MBA Entrance, MCA Entrance, Bank PO, CDS, SSC, Law and Clerical Exams SBI Clerks Preparations, GK Online Preparation and Practice Tests
Number of Questions: 25
Created by:
Tags: Critical Reasoning Reasoning Test Bank Clerical Test Clerical Preparation MBA Reasoning Question MCA Reasoning Question FMS Reasoning SBI Clerks Preparations GK Preparation IQ Test MBA MCA SNAP Entrance Test Architecture Questions LAW CDS SSC Critical Reasoning (Paragraph Based)
Attempted 0/25 Correct 0 Score 0

The price of fish has risen from 40 Rupees a kilogram, three years ago, to 90 Rupees a kilogram today. It is clear that fisheries have been artificially hiking prices and that government regulatory controls are needed to stabilize rising prices.

Which of the following, if true, would most weaken the conclusion made above?

  1. Government agencies already require fisheries to open their locations to investigators from the sanitation department.

  2. Polluted waters and loss of habitat have diminished the number of fish, and therefore, have caused fewer fish to spawn.

  3. Fish often inhabit rivers, which draw large tourist populations.

  4. Technological advances in fish spawning have lowered production costs.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: B
Explanation:

Polluted waters and loss of habitat have diminished the number of fish and therefore have caused fewer fish to be spawned.

Macro Mania entertainment have begun to manufacture new data cables using fiber optic materials rather than previously used copper cables because they are much more efficient and speedier in terms of transfer of data on networks. A cable made of fiber optic material is, however, five times as expensive to produce as a copper cable. It follows that the substitution of fiber optic cables for copper cables is, at this time, not recommended from a financial standpoint.

Which of the following statements, if true, most seriously weakens the argument?

  1. A fiber optic cable costs one-half the price of a copper cable to maintain.

  2. The production of fiber optic cable necessitates Macro Mania entertainment to replace obsolete machinery and to hire extra workers to operate the new machines.

  3. The upkeep of copper cables is far less expensive than the upkeep of any other data cable made from other materials in current production.

  4. While producers anticipate that the cost of fiber optic cables will remain stable, they recognize that the advent of recycling programs for copper should bring down the costs of copper cables.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

This answer indicates that while the fiber optic cable may be more expensive to purchase than a copper cable, over time the lower cost to maintain it may make up for the difference in price.

From 1970 to 1995, millions of tonnes of coal ash from Ropar Thermal Plant was dumped into river Satluj. There is increasing apprehension that the ash will leak contaminants into ground water, and thereafter into drinking water supplied to the cities. This apprehension is unwarranted, as tests of the ground water and local water supply of regions near commercial manufacturers who practiced such dumping during the 1950s showed very little or no evidence of such contaminants.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously undermines the argument above?

  1. Commercial manufacturing plants in the 1950s dumped significantly fewer tonnes of coal ash into river Satluj than did plant from 1970 to 1995.

  2. In the 1950s, coal ash dumped by commercial manufacturing plants contained a greater concentration of harmful agents.

  3. In the 1950s, liquid waste pollution of Satluj constituted a greater hazard to local water supplied than did coal ash during the period from 1970 to 1995.

  4. In recent years, environmentalists have made serious attempts to curb coal ash pollution by commercial manufacturers.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

This answer indicates that the dumping done in the 1950s is not comparable to the dumping done later, so the result of the tests from the 1950s can't be used to predict the results of the increased dumping.

The fact that the word “hunk” has come to be utilized informally as a generic term for attractive men is a lamentable development in the English language. The original meaning of “hunk” is “a large piece of bread, meat.” Therefore, the utilization of “hunk” as a generic term for men is wrong and ought not to be encouraged.
Which of the following is an assumption on which the position above could be based?
  1. The only acceptable meaning of an English word is its original meaning.

  2. The word “hunk” has been used in the English language for hundreds of years.

  3. The utilization of “hunk” as a generic term for men is only a recent development in the language.

  4. Those speaking informal English are not required to use acceptable meanings of words.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

An assumption links the premises to the conclusion, so in order for the utilization of the term “hunk” as a generic term for attractive men to be wrong, the assumption must be that there is only one acceptable meaning of a word.

Critics have recently called into question the authenticity of a piece of pottery, long believed to belong to ancient city of Mohenjo-Daro, which they now believe may have come from Mesopotamian civilization to the city. In order to determine the piece's authenticity, its visual patterns were compared to those in other pieces known to belong to Mesopotamia. Many patterns were examined, including composition and the prominence and width of designs. The patterns displayed by the piece in question were very similar to those in the other genuine items, thereby establishing the authenticity of the given piece.

Which of the following, if true, gives the strongest support to the conclusion above?

  1. The visual patterns displayed by pottery from different civilizations are not likely to be of similar type.

  2. Potters from different civilizations sometimes use the same composition and patterns of designs but did so to achieve different effects.

  3. Many potters endeavored to change their visual patterns with each piece, so as not to grow stale.

  4. The material used for making pottery in all the civilizations is surprisingly limited, thereby ensuring some overlap among the patterns displayed by different patterns.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The assumption is that examining the visual patterns is enough to discern to which civilization the given piece belonged. This answer choice best supports that assumption.

Research indicates that consumer behavior regarding the purchase of soaps varies very little except when the soap contains rose essence. Accordingly, soaps containing the ingredient will have labels indicating that rose essence is present.

Which one of the following is an assumption upon which the above argument is based?

  1. If soap isnot available with the ingredients, then a consumer prefers to buy whatever is available.

  2. The ingredients used in different soaps may differ significantly.

  3. Consumers prefer buying soaps that contains rose essence.

  4. Soap bars labels should reveal all ingredients.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

This argument leaps from 'people are influenced by the presence of rose essence' to 'companies advertise the presence of rose essence.' The assumption on which the given argument is based is that people like rose essence.

The proposal for combined entrance test for MBA colleges, failed to pass by only a slim margin several times in the Directors Syndicate. Twenty-seven votes were required for passage. Twenty-six directors on the Syndicate voted in favor of the proposal in 1999, whereas only 24 directors voted in favor of it in 2001. This was true even though no director changed his or her vote.

Which of the following, if true, best accounts for the change in the number of votes for the proposal from 26 in 1999 to 24 in 2001?

  1. In 1999, the Syndicate's president took a personal interest in the passage of the proposal, while in 2001 the effort was left in the hands of the members of the syndicate.

  2. There was an election in 2000 in which two council members who favored the proposal did not get re-elected to the council and no one who favored the proposal was newly elected.

  3. There was an election in 1999 in which a director who did not favor the proposal was re-elected and the faculty ad hoc committee lost one or its members.

  4. In 2000, a group of directors, not on the syndicate, petitioned extensively to convince the syndicate to oppose the proposal.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: B
Explanation:

This would account for a change in the composition of the syndicate, and so for the change in the vote, without any individual director changing the way he or she voted.

In July 2002, the Indian airline's flights, serving Delhi-Mumbai route, substantially reduced the price of tickets for the flights. During the months, subsequent to the reduction, the number of tickets sold to Mumbai increased to well above the monthly average for the previous year. Despite this fact, the number of tickets sold by Indian airlines to Mumbai was not noticeably different from the previous year's total.

Which of the following, if true, best explains the apparent paradox in the passage above?

  1. Many Indians travel to Mumbai only when airfares are low.

  2. The amount of revenue generated in 2002 by sales of tickets to Mumbai remained the same as it was the previous year.

  3. For first half of 2002, the number of tickets sold for Mumbai was lower than the last year's monthly average.

  4. The larger the number of tickets sold by Indian Airlines in a given one-year period, the lower the pre-ticket price during that period.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

The paradox was based on a comparison of one part of the year to the whole of the previous year. By accounting for the rest of 2002, option (C) resolves the paradox.

Statement I: From 1995 to 2002, the yearly level of infra red rays, to which the average person was exposed, went down considerably.

Statement II: From 1995 to 2002, the occurrence of skin irritation caused by infra red exposure went up threefold from previous levels, which were already high. This was true for those people whose exposure was average for each year during the seven-years period.

Which of the following, if true, would reconcile the apparent inconsistency between Statement I and Statement II?

  1. The skin irritations caused by infra red rays are only temporary.

  2. Atmospheric elements fail to weaken infra red rays.

  3. The period of time between exposure to infra red rays and the incidence of skin irritations caused by such exposure are usually longer than 7 years.

  4. Since 2002, the average level of exposure to infra red rays has gone back up to pre 1995 levels.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

You need to explain why there were more occurrences of skin irritations between 1995 and 2002 even though people were exposed to infrared rays less frequently. This explains that the level of infrared rays does not affect the number of skin irritations between 1995 and 2002 in that time period.

Directions: Read the part of a conversation given below and answer the question that follows it.

Rohit: Our central government seems to function most efficiently when decision-making responsibilities are handled by only a few individuals. Therefore, our government should consolidate its leadership and move away from a parliamentary form of democracy.

Sanjeev: But moving our government in this direction could violate our constitutional mission to provide a parliamentary form of government for the people.

Which of the following statements describes Sanjeev’s response to Rohit?

  1. Sanjeev contradicts the reasoning used by Rohit.

  2. Sanjeev uncovers an assumption used in Rohit’s reasoning.

  3. Sanjeev brings up a possible negative consequence of accepting Rohit’s argument.

  4. Sanjeev reveals the circular reasoning used by Rohit.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The conclusion made by Rohit is contradicted by Sanjeev by giving reference to the constitutional obligation towards the people for the given form of democracy.

A manufacturer for heavy mechanical equipments expects to renovate 5,000 units next year. Yet it is unlikely that a sufficient number of replacements being available, since the number of units being produced at the company have been consistently decreasing over the past five years.

The argument above assumes that

  1. Company production provides for a significant portion of the replacements used by the manufacturer to renovate heavy mechanical equipments.

  2. During the next two years company's production will increase.

  3. In the coming year, no more than 2,500 people will try to purchase renovated units from the manufacturer.

  4. In the previous year, the manufacturer's prediction as to the number of renovated units needed was inaccurate.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

If a significant portion of the replacements did not come from production, then there would be no reason to believe that a lack of production would pose a problem.

Directions: Read the passage given below and answer the question that follows it.

A recent medical journal published a study, which found that athletes who exercised more than five hours per week were more likely than the other athletes to have high levels of chemical compound riboflavin in their blood. High levels of this compound can be one of the first warning signs of skin cancer, which is almost always caused by excessive exposure of the body to water.

Which one of the following, if true, would cast doubt on the study’s conclusion that exercising more than five hours per week increases the odds of contracting skin cancer?

  1. Lack of exercise increases the rate of absorption of many dangerous chemical compounds into the blood stream.

  2. Exercise increases the rate of blood flow through the circulatory system, thereby increasing the rate at which contaminants spread through the body.

  3. Majority of the athletes studied were swimmers.

  4. Athletes contract skin cancer at a significantly higher rate than common people do.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

This is a causal argument and this choice provides an alternative cause for the increased levels of the chemical linked to skin cancer.

Nonprescription sunglasses shield the wearer's eyes from damaging ultraviolet sunlight. Squinting, however, provides protection from ultraviolet rays that are at least as good as the protection from nonprescription sunglasses. There is, therefore, no health advantage to be gained by wearing nonprescription sunglasses rather than squinting.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens support for the conclusion above?

  1. Many opticians offer prescription sunglasses that not only screen out ultraviolet Sunlight but also provide corrective vision.

  2. Some nonprescription sunglasses provide less protection from ultraviolet sunlight than does squinting.

  3. Squinting strains facial muscles and causes headaches and fatigue.

  4. Many people buy sunglasses because they feel that sunglasses are fashionable.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

Headaches and fatigue are health problems that would weaken the argument that squinting is just as good as wearing sunglasses.

Most people with brain tumors undergo surgery. There are many complications that can be associated with any surgery, such as infection. Instead of surgery, doctors should recommend a combination of a modified diet and a non-invasive procedure called radiography, in which the stones are shattered with radio waves.

Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument relies?

  1. Brain tumor surgery is becoming more risky.

  2. Brain tumor surgery has progressed significantly, so the risk of complications has been lowered.

  3. Diet alone is not enough to prevent brain tumor, radiography is necessary as well.

  4. The likelihood of complications resulting from radiography is significantly lower than those associated with any surgery.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

This fills the gap between the premises and conclusion. Otherwise, the author would have no reason to recommend radiography over surgery.

Several members of the Income Tax Department were recently caught taking bribes, therefore, all the government officials are corrupt.

The argument above is most similar to which one of the following?

  1. Recent tax increases have caused inflation; therefore, they should be repealed.

  2. Football is no longer popular among America's youth; therefore, no sport appeals to children.

  3. Some primary schools are unfair because they do not allow students to fail any classes.

  4. Many general practitioners are no longer practicing; therefore, we should encourage current medical students to enter this field.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: B
Explanation:

The argument takes a specific example and bases a huge generalization on it.

Chinese Giant Pandas are rapidly disappearing from their natural habitats. Therefore, to preserve this unique species, pandas must be captured and placed in zoos.

Which of the following, if true, would most seriously weaken the conclusion drawn above?

  1. Captured pandas typically reproduce with greater frequency than they did in their natural habitat.

  2. Newborn pandas in captivity are more likely to survive the diseases that often strike and kill newborn pandas in the wild.

  3. Pandas eat only particular food that cannot be provided in the proper quanty outside of the panda's natural habitat.

  4. There are not enough pandas to provide a breeding pair to each zoo that wants one.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

If pandas cannot be provided with the food they need in captivity, then keeping them in captivity would not help to preserve them.

Since the singers are receiving larger cash rewards and exposure than ever before, many people are encouraging their children to aim for career as singers. Analogously, a few years ago, children were urged to become lawyers, during the enormous upsurge in the profession of barristers. Today, however, it is obvious that there are opportunities for only a tiny fraction of talented lawyers to reach at the higher level of the profession.

The point of the analogy above is that

  1. Professional lawyers are also increasingly likely to become singers.

  2. Singers are becoming more popular than lawyers.

  3. In the future there will be more opportunities for talented lawyers.

  4. There will probably be very few opportunities for many talented singers.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

The conclusion is that, like lawyers in the past, there will be opportunities for only a tiny fraction of talented singers at the professional level. This is the best paraphrase of the conclusion.

A developing country, using socialist form of government, traditionally running in democratic or parliamentary method, will undoubtedly increase the quality of life of its citizens. The country of China presents the most valid example of such form of government, therefore proving the validity of this principle, developing countries like India, which are being run on the principle of democracy. Therefore, in order to become successful the countries should change their form of government.

The flaw in the argument above can best be described as which of the following?

  1. The author avoids the issue by focusing on issues, which are not pertinent.

  2. The author fails to define the critical term “quality of life.”

  3. The author argues circularly by assuming the conclusion is true in stating the principle.

  4. The author generalizes from a specific case that may not necessarily be representative.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

 The assumption here is that what happened in the China is representative of what will happen in all other developing nations. The only evidence the author provides to support his conclusion is the example of the China, which may not be indicative of what will happen in other countries.

Directions: Read the following information carefully and answer the question given below. Within the last 25 years, a large portion of the population of the India has moved from the North to the South. This shift has occurred, not because employment opportunities in the South have expanded, but because, over the same period, the life expectancy of the India's population has increased, and more people therefore move to a warmer climate when they retire.

Which of the following, if true, would strengthen the claim made above that the population now has a greater life expectancy?

  1. Many employment opportunities in the South result from newly built retirement communities.

  2. People less than 70 year old made up less than 10 percent of retirees in 1980 but today account for over 40 percent of retirees.

  3. The segment of the population over 60 years old has increased by two-thirds in the last 20 years, while the entire population has increased by only one-half.

  4. The average cost of living in the South is significantly lower than it is in the North.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

The question concerns the claim that the population now has a greater life expectancy. This answer choice states that the segment of the population over 60 years old is growing at a faster rate than the population as a whole; so more people must be living longer.

Directions: Read the following information carefully and answer the question given below.

During the Indo Pakistan War of 1947, the Pakistan government issued licenses to bandits (armed robbers) who were allowed to plunder Indian areas. Those bandits financed their ventures through the sale of the looted goods. A Pakistani tribesman has petitioned the government to license modern bandits to mount a private “war-for-profit” against smugglers of pirated goods coming from, and going back to, India.

Which of the following, if true, is a drawback to the Pakistani tribesman's proposal?

  1. Modern smugglers are much dangerous than the common Indian people.

  2. Although the Pakistani Constitution still authorizes the licensing of bandits, no licenses have been issued for over 50 years.

  3. Modern bandits would be unable to finance their operations by selling the seized goods without being in violation of the law.

  4. The 1947 bandits looted goods that belonged to citizens of another country.


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

Modern bandits would be unable to finance their operations by selling the seized goods without being in violation of the law because the goods are illegal as they are being smuggled and therefore cannot be legally sold. Also, since the goods are pirated, they cannot be sold legally.

Directions: Read the following information carefully and answer the question given below.The greater the number of autonomous departments in a company, the more essential is a high level of teamwork among them. This is because increased number of autonomous departments demands a large number of mangers who deal with department specific matters, which leads to a greater burden on directors who are assigned the duty to make a universal policy which serves all the individual departments as well as company goals.

There are always greater numbers of autonomous departments in Indian companies than there are in multi national organizations.

Which of the following statements must be true if all of the statements above are true?

  1. Difficulties in setting general policy occur more often in multi national companies than they do in Indian companies.

  2. There are more specialized directors in multi national corporations than there are in Indian companies.

  3. A high level of cooperation is more essential in Indian companies than it is in multi national companies.

  4. A manager's job is easier in an Indian company than it is in multi national company.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

This is an inference question, so you're looking for the one statement that you know is true. We know from the passage that Indian companies have more autonomous departments, and so require a higher level at cooperation.

Directions: Read the following information carefully and answer the question given below.Last year, when the new primary teacher joined the school, she complained to the principal about the noise from another class disturbing her class. The principal's response was that because the teacher was new to the school, she had mistaken the noise coming from the playground for noise coming from another class.

Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the principal's response?

  1. No other class had complained of loud noise within the building.

  2. The new teacher had joined the school to work in an environment where children studied silently.

  3. The new teacher complained about noise before any class went to playground.

  4. Nightclubs tend to produce noise complaints even when they are managed properly.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

If the noise began before anyone went to play in the ground, that would undermine the principal's claim that the noise was coming from the playground.

Directions: Read the passage given below and answer the question that follows it.

Child: All my friends are allowed to watch cartoons and play videogames for longer duration than I am allowed. This practice is unjustifiable.

Mother: You are wrong. If you would complete your homework earlier in the afternoon, you would have plenty of time to watch the cartoons and play videogames.

Which of the following explains why the mother's response to her child is inappropriate?

  1. Some of the child's friends donot watch cartoons and play video games.

  2. The mother does not have to change her child's timing to watch cartoons and play video games.

  3. No matter what time the cartoons and video game's activity begin, the child still has restricted timings for the activities than all of his friends.

  4. On days when the child completed his homework earlier than usual, he stopped watching cartoons earlier than usual.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

The mother is not addressing the child's premise.

Directions: Read the following information carefully and answer the question given below.

A high level of safety in aircraft landing system depends upon by the level of synchronization between the ground control computer and the onboard computer system. To ensure the safety of the aircraft, the aircraft landing system would have to synchronize the two gadgets at regular intervals, and determine that the two are synchronous enough, to make the landing of the aircraft safe. Despite technological advances, every internal computerized system has, during use, proved to have serious limitations, which in certain circumstances would bring about significant failure.

Which of the following can be inferred from the statements above?

  1. If designers are diligent in planning the internal computer systems to be used for aircraft landing system, there is an exceptionally good chance that the given system ensures a high level of safety if and when it is needed.

  2. Techniques for decreasing the number of errors in building on board computer monitoring systems on aircrafts will not be discovered.

  3. Automotive braking systems instead can provide a better viable option.

  4. The safety of aircraft landing system cannot be ensured during synchronization.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

Because the onboard computer system is not glitch free during use, it can be inferred that the sychronization between the onboard computer and the ground control computer will not always be error free. Hence, it can be inferred that the safety of the aircraft cannot be ensured.

Some rats are able to subsist on the barries of the poison sumac, a poisonous plant, by peeling away the poisonous skin of the fruit before they consume it. This method ensures that some rats will always be able to subsist on poison sumac because the plant could never evolve so as to acquire the ability to produce a poison that would prove lethal in the minute quantity left after the fruit is peeled.

The conclusion drawn depends on which of the following assumptions?

  1. The rats that succeed in removing the poisonous skins of the poison sumac are not able to evolve to the point where they are able to detoxify other herbs.

  2. Other types of toxic plants, unlike poison sumac, would be able to surmount their defenselessness through evolutionary modifications.

  3. The poisonous skins of poison sumac can never evolve in a manner such that rats could not successfully peel them.

  4. The method of toxin removal used by rats that eat poison sumac would not produce similar results on other types of toxic herbs.

  5. None of these


Correct Option: E
Explanation:

This argument assumes that the plant would never be able to produce a poison whose minute quantity could prove lethal.

- Hide questions