0

Nominalism vs. Realism: The Debate Over Universals

Description: Nominalism vs. Realism: The Debate Over Universals
Number of Questions: 15
Created by:
Tags: philosophy medieval philosophy nominalism realism universals
Attempted 0/15 Correct 0 Score 0

What is the central question in the debate between nominalism and realism?

  1. Do universals exist independently of particulars?

  2. Are universals real or merely mental constructs?

  3. Do universals have an objective or subjective existence?

  4. All of the above


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

The debate between nominalism and realism centers on the question of whether universals, such as 'humanity' or 'redness', exist independently of particulars, such as individual human beings or red objects.

What is the nominalist position on universals?

  1. Universals are real and exist independently of particulars.

  2. Universals are mental constructs that exist only in the mind.

  3. Universals are neither real nor mental, but rather linguistic conventions.

  4. Universals are both real and mental, depending on the context.


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

Nominalists argue that universals are not real entities that exist independently of particulars, but rather are merely names or labels that we use to group together similar particulars.

What is the realist position on universals?

  1. Universals are real and exist independently of particulars.

  2. Universals are mental constructs that exist only in the mind.

  3. Universals are neither real nor mental, but rather linguistic conventions.

  4. Universals are both real and mental, depending on the context.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

Realists argue that universals are real entities that exist independently of particulars, and that they are the foundation of our knowledge of the world.

Which philosopher is most closely associated with nominalism?

  1. Plato

  2. Aristotle

  3. William of Ockham

  4. Thomas Aquinas


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

William of Ockham is considered to be the most influential nominalist philosopher, and his work had a profound impact on the development of philosophy in the late Middle Ages.

Which philosopher is most closely associated with realism?

  1. Plato

  2. Aristotle

  3. William of Ockham

  4. Thomas Aquinas


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

Thomas Aquinas is considered to be one of the most influential realist philosophers, and his work had a profound impact on the development of philosophy in the late Middle Ages.

What is the principle of parsimony, also known as Ockham's Razor?

  1. The simplest explanation is usually the best.

  2. The more complex the explanation, the more likely it is to be true.

  3. The more entities you postulate, the more likely you are to be wrong.

  4. All of the above


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The principle of parsimony, also known as Ockham's Razor, states that the simplest explanation for a phenomenon is usually the best.

How does the principle of parsimony relate to the debate between nominalism and realism?

  1. Nominalists use the principle of parsimony to argue that universals are not real because they are unnecessary.

  2. Realists use the principle of parsimony to argue that universals are real because they are the simplest explanation for our knowledge of the world.

  3. Both nominalists and realists use the principle of parsimony to support their respective positions.

  4. None of the above


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

Nominalists argue that universals are not real because they are unnecessary, and that the principle of parsimony supports this view.

What is the problem of universals?

  1. The problem of how universals can be both one and many.

  2. The problem of how universals can be both immanent and transcendent.

  3. The problem of how universals can be both real and mental.

  4. All of the above


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

The problem of universals is a complex philosophical problem that has been debated for centuries. It encompasses a number of related questions, including the question of how universals can be both one and many, the question of how universals can be both immanent and transcendent, and the question of how universals can be both real and mental.

What is the solution to the problem of universals proposed by nominalists?

  1. Universals are real and exist independently of particulars.

  2. Universals are mental constructs that exist only in the mind.

  3. Universals are neither real nor mental, but rather linguistic conventions.

  4. Universals are both real and mental, depending on the context.


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

Nominalists argue that the problem of universals can be solved by denying that universals are real entities. They argue that universals are merely names or labels that we use to group together similar particulars.

What is the solution to the problem of universals proposed by realists?

  1. Universals are real and exist independently of particulars.

  2. Universals are mental constructs that exist only in the mind.

  3. Universals are neither real nor mental, but rather linguistic conventions.

  4. Universals are both real and mental, depending on the context.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

Realists argue that the problem of universals can be solved by affirming that universals are real entities. They argue that universals are the foundation of our knowledge of the world, and that they are necessary for us to be able to understand the world around us.

Which of the following is an example of a universal?

  1. Humanity

  2. Redness

  3. Socrates

  4. This table


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

A universal is a concept that applies to many different particulars. Examples of universals include 'humanity', 'redness', 'justice', and 'beauty'.

Which of the following is an example of a particular?

  1. Humanity

  2. Redness

  3. Socrates

  4. This table


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

A particular is a specific individual thing. Examples of particulars include 'Socrates', 'this table', 'the Eiffel Tower', and 'the planet Earth'.

What is the relationship between universals and particulars?

  1. Universals are real and particulars are mental constructs.

  2. Particulars are real and universals are mental constructs.

  3. Universals and particulars are both real.

  4. Universals and particulars are both mental constructs.


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

Realists argue that universals and particulars are both real, and that they are related to each other in a hierarchical fashion. Universals are the higher-level concepts that apply to many different particulars, while particulars are the lower-level entities that instantiate those universals.

What are the implications of nominalism for our understanding of the world?

  1. Nominalism leads to a more fragmented and individualistic view of the world.

  2. Nominalism leads to a more unified and holistic view of the world.

  3. Nominalism has no implications for our understanding of the world.

  4. None of the above


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

Nominalism, by denying the reality of universals, leads to a more fragmented and individualistic view of the world. This is because, if universals are not real, then there is no underlying unity or commonality between different particulars. Each particular is then seen as a unique and isolated entity.

What are the implications of realism for our understanding of the world?

  1. Realism leads to a more fragmented and individualistic view of the world.

  2. Realism leads to a more unified and holistic view of the world.

  3. Realism has no implications for our understanding of the world.

  4. None of the above


Correct Option: B
Explanation:

Realism, by affirming the reality of universals, leads to a more unified and holistic view of the world. This is because, if universals are real, then there is an underlying unity or commonality between different particulars. This unity is provided by the universals that the particulars instantiate.

- Hide questions