0

The Principle of Double Effect: Weighing Intended and Unintended Consequences

Description: The Principle of Double Effect is a moral principle that allows for the performance of an action that has both a good and a bad effect, provided that the good effect is intended and the bad effect is foreseen but not intended. This quiz tests your understanding of the principle and its application to various scenarios.
Number of Questions: 10
Created by:
Tags: ethics moral philosophy double effect
Attempted 0/10 Correct 0 Score 0

Which of the following is a necessary condition for the application of the Principle of Double Effect?

  1. The good effect must be intended.

  2. The bad effect must be intended.

  3. The good effect must outweigh the bad effect.

  4. The action must be performed with the intention of causing the bad effect.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The Principle of Double Effect allows for the performance of an action that has both a good and a bad effect, provided that the good effect is intended and the bad effect is foreseen but not intended.

Which of the following is not a necessary condition for the application of the Principle of Double Effect?

  1. The bad effect must be foreseen.

  2. The good effect must outweigh the bad effect.

  3. The action must be performed with the intention of causing the bad effect.

  4. The action must be performed with the intention of causing the good effect.


Correct Option: B
Explanation:

The Principle of Double Effect does not require that the good effect outweigh the bad effect. However, it does require that the good effect be intended and the bad effect be foreseen but not intended.

Which of the following is an example of an action that would be permitted under the Principle of Double Effect?

  1. Killing an innocent person in order to save five other innocent people.

  2. Lying to someone in order to spare their feelings.

  3. Stealing from a rich person in order to give to a poor person.

  4. Cheating on an exam in order to get a good grade.


Correct Option: B
Explanation:

Lying to someone in order to spare their feelings is an example of an action that would be permitted under the Principle of Double Effect because the good effect (sparing someone's feelings) is intended and the bad effect (lying) is foreseen but not intended.

Which of the following is an example of an action that would not be permitted under the Principle of Double Effect?

  1. Killing an innocent person in order to save five other innocent people.

  2. Lying to someone in order to spare their feelings.

  3. Stealing from a rich person in order to give to a poor person.

  4. Cheating on an exam in order to get a good grade.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

Killing an innocent person in order to save five other innocent people is an example of an action that would not be permitted under the Principle of Double Effect because the bad effect (killing an innocent person) is intended.

Which of the following is a common objection to the Principle of Double Effect?

  1. It is too difficult to apply in practice.

  2. It is based on a false dichotomy between good and bad effects.

  3. It is too permissive and allows for the justification of immoral actions.

  4. It is too restrictive and does not allow for the performance of necessary actions.


Correct Option: C
Explanation:

A common objection to the Principle of Double Effect is that it is too permissive and allows for the justification of immoral actions. Critics argue that the principle allows for the performance of actions that have foreseeable bad effects, even if those effects are not intended.

Which of the following is a common defense of the Principle of Double Effect?

  1. It is a necessary tool for making moral decisions in complex situations.

  2. It is based on a sound understanding of human nature.

  3. It is consistent with the teachings of major religious traditions.

  4. It is the only moral principle that can be applied consistently to all situations.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

A common defense of the Principle of Double Effect is that it is a necessary tool for making moral decisions in complex situations. Defenders argue that the principle allows for the consideration of all relevant factors in a moral decision, including the intended and unintended effects of an action.

The Principle of Double Effect is most closely associated with which philosopher?

  1. Thomas Aquinas

  2. John Stuart Mill

  3. Immanuel Kant

  4. Friedrich Nietzsche


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The Principle of Double Effect is most closely associated with the philosopher Thomas Aquinas. Aquinas developed the principle in the 13th century as a way to address the moral problems posed by actions that have both good and bad effects.

Which of the following is an example of a situation in which the Principle of Double Effect might be applied?

  1. A doctor performing surgery on a patient, knowing that there is a risk of death.

  2. A soldier killing an enemy combatant in war.

  3. A police officer shooting a fleeing suspect.

  4. A parent spanking their child.


Correct Option: A
Explanation:

The Principle of Double Effect might be applied in a situation where a doctor is performing surgery on a patient, knowing that there is a risk of death. The doctor intends to save the patient's life, but they foresee the possibility of death as an unintended consequence of the surgery.

Which of the following is an example of a situation in which the Principle of Double Effect would not be applied?

  1. A doctor performing surgery on a patient, knowing that there is a risk of death.

  2. A soldier killing an enemy combatant in war.

  3. A police officer shooting a fleeing suspect.

  4. A parent spanking their child.


Correct Option: D
Explanation:

The Principle of Double Effect would not be applied in a situation where a parent is spanking their child. The parent intends to punish the child, and the pain that the child experiences is an intended consequence of the spanking.

The Principle of Double Effect is a complex and controversial moral principle. What is your opinion on the principle? Do you think it is a useful tool for making moral decisions?


Correct Option:
Explanation:

This is an open-ended question that allows students to express their own opinions on the Principle of Double Effect. There is no right or wrong answer.

- Hide questions